Hi Kim, yeah, I too ran Pulstars in my '85 Subie, probably 6 years ago. I too felt some improvements at first, I noticed a deeper idle exhaust tone, and a bit more power. After maybe a year, I swapped 'em out for the stockers, and noticed no change.
Sounds like potential QC problems for Pulstars. For "trick" plugs, I run stainless torquemasters from extreme spark dot com. I've had those in Subie 5 years this coming Spring, as necessary to the Plasma spark ignition upgrade. Still goin' strong.
torquemasters are a surface discharge design, you can't gap 'em. I like em!
Tracy G